Government drops wider judge alone trial plan but major court reforms remain

The Government has changed course on one of the most controversial parts of the Courts and Tribunals Bill. On 4 October 2026, the Ministry of Justice announced that it would abandon the proposed Crown Court “Bench Division”, under which some triable-either-way cases would have been tried by a judge without a jury.

That is an important change, but it does not mean that the wider reforms to jury trial, magistrates’ court powers and criminal appeals have been withdrawn. Several proposals with significant consequences for defendants remain.

What has been withdrawn

The Bill’s published text proposed a new division of the Crown Court for triable-either-way cases expected to attract a sentence of three years or less. Those cases could have been tried by a judge alone.

The Justice Secretary has now said that this plan will be removed when the Bill returns to Parliament. More serious cases will therefore continue to be tried before juries in the ordinary Crown Court.

This announcement is not yet reflected throughout the Government’s published factsheet, which still describes the proposed Bench Division. Formal amendments are expected when the Bill returns to the House of Commons on 13 October.

Which proposals remain

The Government intends to retain a separate power allowing suitably technical and lengthy fraud or financial cases to be tried by a judge alone. Under the published proposal, eligibility would depend on specified financial offences and an exceptional-complexity or length preparatory hearing, with certain homicide and sexual offences excluded. The court would also have to be satisfied that the case was suitably technical and lengthy and that jury trial was not in the public interest.

More broadly, the Government continues to propose:

• removing a defendant’s right to elect Crown Court trial for a triable-either-way offence where the magistrates’ court accepts jurisdiction;

• allowing the Crown Court to remit a case to the magistrates’ court without the defendant’s consent;

• replacing the automatic right of appeal from the magistrates’ court with a permission stage, and replacing a full rehearing with an appeal limited to the issues for which permission is granted; and

• enabling magistrates’ sentencing powers to be increased to 18 or 24 months’ imprisonment.

The Government has also announced that the legislation will require an independent review of the effect of the structural reforms on ethnic-minority defendants and people from different backgrounds.

What this means for defendants now

These proposals are not yet law. The existing rules continue to apply. A defendant charged today with a triable-either-way offence retains the present right to elect Crown Court trial if the magistrates accept jurisdiction. The present appeal route from the magistrates’ court to the Crown Court also remains available without the proposed permission stage.

If enacted, however, the reforms would give much greater importance to the allocation hearing in the magistrates’ court. Decisions made at an early stage could determine both the trial venue and the sentencing powers available following conviction. The proposed appeal changes would also make it more important to identify and preserve disputed issues during the original proceedings, because an appeal would no longer ordinarily amount to a fresh hearing of the whole case.

Anyone facing a triable-either-way allegation should obtain advice before indicating a plea or making representations about venue. The appropriate court depends on the evidence, legal complexity, likely sentence and the individual circumstances of the case.

Peter Bonner & Co will continue to monitor the amendments when they are published and the Bill’s progress through Parliament.

Contact Peter Bonner & Co for advice about your case: https://peterbonner-co-uk.com/contact

General crime: https://peterbonner-co-uk.com/criminal-defence

Private defence: https://peterbonner-co-uk.com/private-defence

Appeals and second opinions: https://peterbonner-co-uk.com/appeals-and-second-opinions

Author: Peter Bonner & Co. Approved for publication: Christopher Carter, solicitor, 5 October 2026.

This article provides general information about proposed law in England and Wales as at 5 October 2026. The Bill may change before becoming law. This is not legal advice; advice should be obtained on the facts of an individual case.

Sources

Ministry of Justice announcement, 4 October 2026: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/justice-reforms-to-be-rolled-out-faster-as-justice-secretary-sets-out-changes-to-courts-bill

Courts and Tribunals Bill factsheet: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/courts-and-tribunals-bill/courts-and-tribunals-bill-factsheet

UK Parliament: https://bills.parliament.uk/bills/4083

Previous
Previous

New domestic abuse finding at sentencing: what defendants need to know

Next
Next

A suspended sentence after multiple Crown Court cases